Ranch vs. Two-Story: Which Floor Plan Is Right for Your Family?

One of the biggest decisions you’ll make when building a new home is whether to go with a ranch or a two-story layout. Both have real advantages, and the right choice depends on how your family lives day to day, not just what looks good from the street. Destiny Homes offers ranch, 1.5-story, and two-story floor plans across 30+ communities in the Des Moines metro, so there’s no shortage of options. The question is which one fits you.

Why This Decision Matters More Than You Think

Your floor plan affects everything: how you move through your home each morning, where the kids do homework, how much yard space you get, what your utility bills look like, and how the home works for you ten or twenty years from now. It’s not something you want to figure out after you’ve already moved in.

The good news is there’s no wrong answer here. It comes down to priorities. Let’s walk through what each layout actually offers.

The Case for a Ranch

Single-Level Living

Everything on one floor. No hauling laundry baskets up and down stairs, no second-floor noise carrying through the house at night. Ranch plans put every room on the same level, which makes daily routines simpler.

Accessibility and Aging in Place

If you’re thinking long term, a ranch is easier to live in at any age. No stairs means fewer mobility concerns down the road. According to the National Association of Home Builders, single-story homes have consistently ranked as the most-wanted home feature among buyers aged 55 and older. But this matters for younger families too, especially those with aging parents or anyone who wants a forever home.

Easier Maintenance

Cleaning gutters, painting exteriors, and maintaining the roof are all easier on a single-story structure. It’s a small thing until you’re paying someone $800 to pressure wash a two-story facade.

The Case for a Two-Story

More Square Footage on a Smaller Lot

If lot size is a factor, a two-story home gives you more interior space without eating up your entire yard. You get the same (or more) square footage stacked vertically, which leaves room for a backyard, a patio, or a play area. That’s a big deal in some of our more popular Des Moines metro communities where lot sizes are tighter.

Natural Separation Between Living and Sleeping Areas

Having bedrooms upstairs and living spaces downstairs creates a clear division between active and quiet zones. When the kids are asleep on the second floor, you can still watch TV, clean the kitchen, or have people over without tiptoeing around. That separation is one of the most common reasons families choose a two-story layout.

Curb Appeal and Resale Value

Two-story homes tend to have a more dramatic street presence. That’s subjective, of course, but it’s worth noting that in many Des Moines suburbs, two-story homes often sell at a slight premium per square foot compared to ranches of similar size and finish level.

What About a 1.5-Story?

A 1.5-story layout is a middle ground that more buyers should know about. You get the primary bedroom on the main floor (the biggest selling point of a ranch) with additional bedrooms upstairs. It’s the best of both worlds for families who want single-level living for the parents but need the extra space for kids or guests. Check out our Belle plan to see how this layout feels in person.

How to Decide: Questions to Ask Yourself

Before you pick a floor plan, sit down and think through a few questions:

How old are your kids (or will they be when you move in)? Families with very young children sometimes prefer ranches for safety. Families with older kids often like the privacy a two-story provides.

Do you plan to stay in this home long term? If you’re building your forever home, a ranch gives you more flexibility as you age. If you’ll likely move in 7-10 years, a two-story with strong curb appeal may serve you better.

How important is outdoor space? A two-story layout maximizes yard space. A ranch spreads out across the lot.

What does your budget look like? Ranch and two-story homes overlap in price at Destiny Homes, but the cost per square foot can differ. Check our photo gallery to see finished examples of both styles.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are ranch homes more expensive per square foot than two-story homes?

Often, yes. Ranches require a larger foundation and roof relative to their total square footage, which can increase the per-square-foot cost compared to a two-story of the same size. But the total price depends on the specific plan, finishes, and lot.

Which floor plan has better resale value in Iowa?

Both sell well in the Des Moines metro. Ranches are in high demand among empty nesters and retirees. Two-stories appeal to growing families. The best resale value comes from a well-maintained home in a desirable community, regardless of layout.

Can you customize a ranch or two-story plan with Destiny Homes?

Yes. Every home includes a design appointment where you choose your finishes, from siding color and stone to countertops and flooring. Our building process walks you through how customization works.

What is a 1.5-story home?

A 1.5-story home has the primary bedroom and main living areas on the first floor, with additional bedrooms upstairs. It combines the convenience of single-level living with the extra space of a two-story.

See the Floor Plans for Yourself

The best way to decide is to see the layouts side by side. Browse all of our available floor plans to compare ranch, 1.5-story, and two-story options by square footage, bedrooms, and price. When you’re ready to talk specifics, contact our sales team or call (515) 216-1015.

References

National Association of Home Builders. “Housing Trends Report.” NAHB, 2024. https://www.nahb.org/news-and-economics/housing-economics/indices/housing-trends-report.